Temporary HP vs. Aid & Max-HP Buffs: The Exact Stacking Rules
Nothing causes more healing confusion at 5e tables than mixing Temporary Hit Points with Maximum Hit Point buffs. Because the distinction determines both your total HP buffer and whether you can be healed back up after taking a hit, memorize this single two-part rule:
- Temporary HP Never Stacks: Temp HP is a separate disposable cushion sitting outside your real HP pool. You cannot add Temp HP from False Life onto Temp HP from Armor of Agathys or Inspiring Leader. When two effects award Temporary HP, you keep whichever pool you choose (nearly always the higher value). Furthermore, healing spells like Cure Wounds or Short Rest Hit Dice cannot restore lost Temporary HP.
- Max-HP Increases Stack With Everything: Spells like Aid (+5 per slot level above 1st, lasting 8 hours with no Concentration) and Heroes' Feast (+2d10 for 24 hours) raise your actual Current and Maximum Hit Points. Because they are real HP rather than Temp HP, you can freely combine Aid + Heroes' Feast + one strong source of Temporary HP!
Common 5e Temporary HP & Max-HP Sources
| Feature / Spell | Pool Type | Stacks w/ Temp HP? | Amount Granted | Duration & Key Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aid (2nd-level+ spell) | Real Max HP | Yes (Stacks) | 5 HP per slot level (Lv2+) | 8 hours; heals downed allies up to +5/+10/+15! |
| Heroes' Feast (6th-level) | Real Max HP | Yes (Stacks) | +2d10 HP (Avg +11) | 24 hours; works cleanly alongside Aid + Temp HP. |
| Inspiring Leader Feat | Temporary HP | No (Takes highest) | Character Lvl + Cha/Wis | Free party-wide buffer on every Short or Long Rest. |
| Armor of Agathys | Temporary HP | No (Takes highest) | 5 HP per spell slot level | Deals cold damage back while these Temp HP remain. |
| False Life / Fiendish Vigor | Temporary HP | No (Takes highest) | 1d4+4 (2024: 2d4+4 = 9 avg) | Warlocks with Fiendish Vigor always start combat with max roll (12 in 2024). |
| 2024 Wild Shape / Polymorph | Temporary HP | No (Takes highest) | Druid Lvl (or 3x Moon Druid) | Massive 2024 rule update keeping real HP safe underneath. |